Developmental states, african development, africaasia. Given the continental scale and divergent politicalinstitutional setups of china and india, the book considers whether the concept of the developmental state can shed light on the processes and prospects of their economic transformation, and whether the dynamic interaction between the central and local states undermines or promotes development. Faculty of engineering and the built environment university of johannesburg auckland park, johannesburg, 2006 south africa email. Developmental state theories centre on these ideas of active state interventionism to facilitate rapid industrialization and economic growth for lateindustrializing countries. This is in marked contrast to the dominant consensus that held sway for the previous two decades, which stated that developmental progress in poor societies wasbest assured by strong states, ruled by authoritarian regimes. Bdswg aims to bring together researchers who use marxist and heterodox political economy to examine the causes, consequences, incidence and dynamics of state intervention in and across the developed and developing world. The author is grateful to the managing editor and an anonymous referee, as well as jamshid bahar, michael lim, michael gordy and daniel taklegeorgis for their helpful comments and discussions on various versions of the paper. Developmental state, n the government, motivated by desire for economic advancement, intervenes in industrial affairs. The case of the japanese and south korean steel industries 33 hajime sato 3 an alternative perspective on industrial policy. The concept of the developmental state emerged to explain the rapid growth of a number of countries in east asia in the postwar period. The developmental state some comparative reflections it is appropriate to begin with some general characteristics of a developmental state. Rather, the developmental state tried to achieve its goals through a set of instruments such as tax credits, breaks, subsidies, import controls, export. This paper discusses component for an effective and efficient implementation of the rule of law in a developmental state from an african perspective. Growing inequality in mauritius sheila bunwaree abstract the small multiethnic island state of mauritius has made great strides and embraced the notion of equal opportunity for all, although this has not always been translated in practice.
Public service leadership for a developmental state in. For scholars, students and practitioners of development, beyond the developmental state presents a decisive break with the old dogmas of both neoliberal orthodoxy and theories of marketimperfection, and outlines theoretically and empirically grounded alternatives. Democracy, developmental state and development extract from chapter 7. Since the 1997 asian crisis, a vigorous debate has taken place as to the continued relevance of the concept of the developmental state in advancing our understanding of the nature of contemporary south korea weiss 2003. A case for technical education professor tshilidzi marwala executive dean. Introduction our government has committed itself to building a developmental state in south africa. Research report 108 the emerging south african democratic. Professor anthony butler a thesis submitted to the faculty of arts, university of the witwatersrand, johannesburg, in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts. This is based on the recognition that to overcome our triple developmental challenges unemployment, poverty and inequality, as well as to. Article information, pdf download for the enduring relevance of the. One remarkable feature of the discourse on the state and development in africa is the disjuncture between an analytical tradition that insists on the impossibility of developmental states in africa and a prescriptive literature that presupposes their existence. In 2009 the developmental state was a focal point of the state of the nation address sona by president jacob zuma as well as of the 2009 medium term strategic framework. The pursuit of a developmental state agenda is thus currently official policy of the south african government. The persistence of developmental states 48 conclusion 55 chapter 2.
Ugandas institutional framework for development since colonialism. Jun, 2017 one particular theory, which is increasingly popular in south africa, is the socalled developmental state. Critics charge that japans success in putting this notion into practice has not been replicated elsewhere, that the concept threatens the purity of freemarket economics, and that. Abstract previous studies on economic development in east asia focus exclusively on the recent period since the 1960s and posit that east asian miracles were largely a result of the states exceptional capacity to implement consistent industrial policy. Leadership, governance and a dialogue in public sector finance.
These changing roles of the state have had an impact on developing countries. Sinocentric legacies and the preconditions for the ds 60 2. Mainstream economists explained their success as the result of following the western prescription, while other scholars attributed this rapid growth to the developmental state. In this model of capitalism sometimes referred to as state development capitalism, the state has more independent, or autonomous, political power, as well as more control over the. The 1990s have witnessed the ascendance of a new orthodoxy which asserts that democracy and development are mutually reinforcing. He was awarded both the deutscher and myrdal prizes in 2009. On that basis it then highlights some issues for research on the democratic developmental state in africa. These debates all crystallise around the notion of a developmental state. Yet, they neglect the question of the origins of the developmental state.
Beyond the developmental state east asias political economies. Beyond this debate, the multiple meanings of sustainable development allowed. The developmental state model and analytical tools 58 2. It argues that the developmental state model is still an effective development strategy in the postcold war period and even in the era of globalization. The concept and evolution of the developmental state. I am grateful for the valuable feedback received at the developmental states beyond east asia workshop, 5 june 2015, at newcastle university. Originating from a description of the south east asian growth experience, this term.
A developmental state in africa what can policy makers in africa learn from the idea of developmental state. The concept and evolution of the developmental state article pdf available in international journal of political economy 373. Keywords developmental state, agriculture, oil, industrialisation, nigeria. Developmental state is often conceptually positioned between liberal open economy model and a centralplanned model. Theoretical origins of the developmental state 28 1. The developmental state in the era of globalization. The developmental state is based on combinations of positive advantages private business and the positive role of government. Yet the developmental state literature also offered a theoretical approach to growth that was heterodox with respect to prevailing approaches in both economics and political science.
Pdf new media and the developmental state in ethiopia. However, the developmental state situation in east asia was exceptional in every dimension. Its roots are drawn from the theory of mercantilism advocating intervention of the state in the economy. For many newly independent developing countries in the 1950s and 1960s, much faith abounded in the role of the state as an agent of economic development as opposed to the role of market forces enshrined in the invisible hand of adam smith. In this model of capitalism sometimes referred to as state development capitalism, the state has more independent, or autonomous, political power. Most recently in 2012, building a developmental state featured. Ben fine is professor of economics at soas, university of london. The potentiality of developmental states in africa. The challenges of building a democratic developmental state.
The case of the south korean car industry 61 kwonhyung lee 4 labour and the developmental state. Democracy and the developmental state meles zenawi. Developmental state imperative in africa united nations. Unraveling meles zenawis concept of developmental state. The developmental state, government, and singapores. Jul 03, 2017 the developmental state ds literature puts competent and autonomous public institutions at the kernel of developmental success and effective state intervention.
A recent assessment of this developmental state literature is meredith woocumings, the developmental state ithaca, n. Ben fine is professor of economics, school of oriental and african studies, university of london and senior research fellow attached to the south african research chair in social change, university of johannesburg. Beyond development complete transnational institute. Economic development, inequality, colonialism, the developmental state, east asia in 1820, the richest country in east asia was the philippines, while the poorest area was todays taiwan. Promising democratic developmental state in africa. State, development and inequality soas research online. The east asian development state as a reference model for. An institutionalpolicy analysis of the postapartheid political economy by khwezi mabasa 04423089 submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree. One particular theory, which is increasingly popular in south africa, is the socalled developmental state. This chapter argues that the country can no longer usefully be regarded as a developmental state. Revisiting the developmental state speri the university of. The notion of the developmental state has come under attack in recent years. The statist perspective is found lacking in its claims to explain. Developmental states by stephan haggard cambridge core.
The theory of developmental state isnt capitalist or socialist. The asian developmental state and the flying geese paradigm shigehisa kasahara no. He is the author of pradors pluto, 2012 and coeditor of beyond the developmental state pluto, 20. Through this approach, the contributors show the close interrelation between states and markets in both national and international contexts. The developmental state, government, and singapores economic development since 1960. The developmental state, the evolving international. The developmental state is therefore usually associated with the rapidly growing east asian countries. Pdf the concept and evolution of the developmental state. While economists usually agree on the regulatory functions of the statee. East asian countries fulfill the characteristic features mostly used. The standard economic argument also takes its theoretical imperative of state structure and the capacity to intervene from max weber. The first part analyses a just legal framework needed in a developmental state. The concluding section summarises the key features of a democratic developmental state.
The term developmental state does not enjoy any clear consensus about its meaning. Developmental state, or hard state, is a term used by international political economy scholars to refer to the phenomenon of stateled macroeconomic planning in east asia in the late 20th century. Developmental state imperative in africa pretoria, south africa 28july 2015 eca an academician at the university of botswana has underscored the importance of africa building democratic developmental states, citing the southern africa diamond endowed nation, botswana, that was able to graduate from underdevelopment by adopting a. If you want to understand how and why japans governement functions, and get at least a solid introduction to the developmental state this book is a must read. Second, this did no imply that it made heavy use of public ownership. Presentation to modern africa, msc africa and international development, university of edinburgh. For the role of the state in african cases, see richard sandbrook, politics of africas economic stagnation cambridge. Rethinking colonialism and the origins of the developmental. Developmental state, or hard state, is a term used by international political economy scholars to refer to the phenomenon of state led macroeconomic planning in east asia in the late 20th century. It has a level of taxation perhaps supplemented by aid sufficient to provide public expenditure on physical infrastructure, education and health, significantly higher than in economies following the liberal market model, in the. Originating from a description of the south east asian growth experience, this term generally refers to a country that is committed to using state institutions to drive economic development or bolster the social welfare of their. Human development, state transformation and the politics. Daniela tavasci lectures at the school of economics and finance, queen mary university of london. Pdf this book devises an innovative new way of explaining how socioeconomic orders shape capitalism in asia.
A theoretical and methodological critique external factors as det erminan ts of national economic factors, with primacy being giving to the former gore, 1996. The developmental state ds literature puts competent and autonomous public institutions at the kernel of developmental success and effective state intervention. South korea after the developmental state springerlink. In addition to working in the financial sector for seven years, she is the coeditor of beyond the developmental state pluto, 20.
Public service leadership for a developmental state in south. The developmental state model we might summarize the developmental state model as follows. An introduction 1 ben fine 2 the rise and fall of the developmental state. The developmental state of the twentyfirst century. It is also a good way to get a solid introduction to the developmental state form of economic control and management which worked so well in japan, korea, taiwan and now china. Evidences from ethiopia demeke atlaw melke department of public policy and leadership, park chung hee school of policy and saemaul psps. Some even question the appropriateness of the term developmental state contending that a state as an abstract entity can neither be developmental nor nondevelopmental, and it is perhaps a regime, they contend, that may deserve such a label. Public service leadership for a developmental state in south africa. Within the realm of governance and growth studies, there are various theories regarding the role of the state in promoting economic growth and supporting development.
New media and the developmental state in ethiopia article pdf available in african affairs 1451. Within developmental state theories, development is synonymous with economic or industrial growth and a result of conscious state policies and implementation of. Thinking about developmental states in africa thandika mkandawire. Democracy and the developmental state meles zenawi horn. The institutional framework of the developmental state in botswana.
The developmental state, government, and singapores economic. Human development, state transformation and the politics of. He is the author of the critical texts, macroeconomics and microeconomics pluto, 2016, coauthor of marxs capital pluto, 2016 and coeditor of beyond the developmental state pluto, 20. This essay compares these two explanations of successful economic development, concluding in favour of the latter with respect to the catch.
The theory and practice of building developmental states in the. Moving beyond abstract economic models and superficial descriptions of the market, beyond the developmental state analyses the economic, political and ideological interests which underpin current socioeconomic processes. The rule of law is the ideal that states strive for. He is the author of theories of social capital pluto, 2010 and coauthored the awardwinning books from economics imperialism to freakonomics 2009 and. The role of the rule of law in a developmental state in the. Second, this article directly counters new criticism of the developmental state. Vision paper presented at the eadi general conference bonn 2123 september 2005 table of contents. Pdf this paper considers the contribution of the developmental state literature to comparative. The enduring relevance of the developmental state paradigm. The developmental state and strategic industrial policy chalmers johnson is the pioneer of the concept of the capitalist developmental state. They show that the status of these socalled developmental states. Beyond developmental state working group working group guide statement.
1323 387 629 193 996 455 1479 1192 1039 1069 151 801 765 421 738 616 1343 840 16 1030 363 872 478 1323 1487 1404 36 438 1044 916 332